Sola Scriptura: Are Protestants Their Own Popes? Responding to John Bergsma and Matt Fradd

Movements (evangelicalism, spiritualism, doctrinal trends, etc. )

Sola Scriptura: Are Protestants Their Own Popes? Responding to John Bergsma and Matt Fradd

40 min

Movements (evangelicalism, spiritualism, doctrinal trends, etc. )

Sola Scriptura: Are Protestants Their Own Popes? Responding to John Bergsma and Matt Fradd

40 min

Does sola scriptura lead to chaos and individualism? Catholic theologian John Bergsma and Catholic podcaster Matt Fradd claim that rejecting the magisterium leaves Protestants without interpretive authority. Michael Horton, Bob Hiller, Walter Strickland, and Justin Holcomb answer this challenge by clarifying the Protestant doctrine of Scripture’s sufficiency, clarity, and final authority. 


on this episode

  • Michael Horton (Ph.D.,Wycliffe Hall, Oxford and Coventry University) is the J. Gresham Machen Professor of Systematic Theology and Apologetics at Westminster Seminary California and Founder & Editor-in-Chief of Sola Media.
  • Justin Holcomb is a Senior Fellow with Sola Media’s Theo Global. He is also the bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of Central Florida, where he has served as the canon for vocations since 2013. He teaches theology and apologetics at Reformed Theological Seminary and Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary.
  • Bob Hiller is the Senior Pastor of Community Lutheran Church in Escondido, California. He is also the author of Finding Christ in the Straw.
  • Walter Strickland is Assistant Professor of Systematic and Contextual Theology at Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary. He has contributed to, edited, and authored multiple books in his areas of research interest, which include the African American theological tradition, education theory, and theology of work.

Bob Hiller is the Senior Pastor of Community Lutheran Church in Escondido/San Marcos, California. He is the author of Finding Christ in the Straw and the content editor for The Craft of Preaching (1517).

Justin S. Holcomb, PhD, is an Episcopal minister and professor of theology at Reformed Theological Seminary and Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary. He has authored, coauthored, or edited more than twenty books on numerous topics, including abuse, biblical studies, and theology. Justin and his wife, Lindsey, coauthored the award-winning children’s book God Made All of Me, God Made Me in His Image, and God Made Babies. You can read more from Justin at justinholcomb.com and connect with him on Twitter @JustinHolcomb.

Michael S. Horton serves as the founder and Editor in Chief of Sola Media and serves as the J. Gresham Machen Professor of Apologetics and Systematic Theology at Westminster Seminary California.

More from Movements (evangelicalism, spiritualism, doctrinal trends, etc. )

Explore All
A pendulum swinging over a sketched compass.

Progressive Christianity’s Metamodern Posture

What does an elder who is leaving a local evangelical church because—in part—he felt this church wasn’t taking social justice issues seriously have in common with another Christian who is forsaking Classical Theism for Open Theism? Further, what unites these with a third Christian whose journey […]

America’s Crisis Over Eschatology

America’s Crisis Over Eschatology

How did American evangelicals move from being largely postmillennial to embracing premillennial dispensationalism? Michael Horton, Justin Holcomb, Walter Strickland, and Bob Hiller explore how both liberals and fundamentalists have often shared faulty assumptions about history, and how those assumptions have shaped the church’s outlook, shifting it from triumphalism to pessimism rather than cultivating a posture […]

The Crises That Created Christian Fundamentalism

The Crises That Created Christian Fundamentalism

How did American Protestantism fracture into fundamentalism and liberalism? Michael Horton, Justin Holcomb, Walter Strickland, and Bob Hiller explore the context of the late 19th century, examine the influence of “Common Sense Realism” on Americans’ hermeneutics and how it cracked under the crises of Darwinism and German higher criticism. on this episode

The Pope or 30,000 Denominations? White Horse Inn Responds to Bishop Robert Barron

The Pope or 30,000 Denominations? White Horse Inn Responds to Bishop Robert Barron

Bishop Barron argues that the Reformation’s legacy is 30,000 denominations and doctrinal chaos. Is Protestantism fatally fractured? Michael Horton, Bob Hiller, Walter Strickland, and Justin Holcomb address the charge of division by exploring the Protestant understanding of visible and invisible church unity, the authority of Scripture, and the nature of confessional agreement. on this episode

Join thousands, reach millions

Be a theological lifeline for Christians through your monthly gift.

Give Monthly